10 Substitutes For RumChata: Creamy, Boozy Alternatives For Mixing Delicious Cocktails

RumChata has become my go-to liqueur lately thanks to its sweet and spicy flavor profile. This cream liqueur combines premium Caribbean rum with vanilla, cinnamon, and velvety dairy cream to create an indulgent spirit that works wonders in cocktails and even coffee. However, I want to mix things up and try some substitutes that offer similar boozy decadence.

In this article, I’ll recommend my top substitutes for RumChata that can infuse baked goods and cocktails with sublime flavors. Whether you love the cinnamon kick or creamy mouthfeel of RumChata, these substitutes aim to please. I’ll also provide a recipe to make your own homemade RumChata so you can avoid the liquor store entirely!

10 Substitutes For RumChata

So curl up with your favorite cocktail glass or mixer, and let’s explore some sensational substitutes for RumChata.

Spiced Horchata – Ricura

Ricura bills itself as the original Latin American horchata cream liqueur. It’s made with Barbados rum blended with Hispanic ingredients like rice, sugar, cinnamon, and milk. The result? A sweet yet spicy cream liqueur with a more dominant rum flavor compared to RumChata.

The cinnamon and rum dance together beautifully in this liqueur, offering hints of rice pudding and freshly baked bread. Ricura works wonderfully in cocktails like mudslides, B-52s, and white Russians. Feel free to drizzle it over ice cream too for a festive dessert cocktail.

Indian-Inspired Cream – Somrus

If you want a cream liqueur with an exotic twist, grab a bottle of Somrus. This liqueur incorporates enticing Indian flavors like cardamom, saffron, rose, and pistachios along with a aged Caribbean rum base.

With its unique blend of spices and rum, Somrus adds incredible depth to cocktails. I love using it to make a Cinnamon Toast Crunch shot or other Indian-inspired drinks. Somrus is on the sweeter side, so add it slowly until you achieve the intended flavor.

Sweet ‘N Spicy – Ponche Kuba

From Mexico comes Ponche Kuba, a rum-forward cream liqueur with an intense cinnamon kick. It combines aged rum with spices like vanilla, nutmeg, and cloves for a festive sweet yet spicy flavor.

This Christmas-ready liqueur works wonderfully in winter warmers like hot toddies. Ponche Kuba also shines in Espresso Martinis, Snickerdoodle Martinis, and other cocktails demanding a sweet and spicy kick.

Decadent Chocolate Dessert – Mozart Chocolate Cream

Calling all chocolate lovers! This Austrian chocolate cream liqueur takes decadence to the next level. Mozart Chocolate Cream Liqueur combines fine chocolate and cocoa with spirits, cream, vanilla, and cocoa butter.

The result? Liquid velvet in a bottle. For chocolate fans, this rum-based liqueur makes dessert drinks shine. Blend it into boozy milkshakes, pour it over ice cream, or use it in chocolate martinis and other cocktails. Its rich flavor also works nicely in chocolate cakes, brownies, and lush puddings.

Creamy Cocoa Bliss – Orovana Rum Cream Liqueur

Hailing from Spain, Orovana rum cream dazzles the senses with its soft and creamy mouthfeel. This rum-based liqueur highlights luscious cocoa and vanilla flavors without overwhelming booziness.

Orovana may remind you of liqueurs like Bailey’s, but with a more pronounced rum backbone. Its gentle flavors allow it to blend nicely into White Russians and other cocktails, adding a kiss of sweetness. Feel free to enjoy it chilled or drizzled over cakes too.

Tropical Twist – Sangster’s Rum Cream

Jamaican flavors permeate this rum cream liqueur from Sangster’s. It combines Jamaican overproof rum with luscious coconut and hints of coffee and banana.

The result? A tropical taste sensation. Sangster’s rum cream fills in nicely for RumChata in tiki drinks, Pina Coladas, mudslides, and other cocktails. Its fruit-forward flavor also works nicely blended into smoothies or swirled into ice cream.

Spiced Caramel – Stroh Cream

Austria’s Stroh Cream Liqueur offers a nice change of pace with its spiced rum base. This 80-proof liqueur bursts with sweet caramel flavor along with cinnamon, vanilla, and almond.

Stroh Cream boasts a much spicier profile compared to RumChata. This allows it to shine in festive cocktails like B-52s, Irish Alexanders, and Irish Slammers. Feel free to experiment by swapping it into any cocktail calling for a spiced rum cream.

Coconut Bliss – Mangaroca Batida de Coco

This Brazilian liqueur offers a tropical escape with each sip. Mangaroca Batida de Coco combines aged cachaça rum or vodka with luscious coconut cream and raw coconut water.

The result? An ultra-refreshing elixir bursting with coconut and subtle tropical fruit. Mangaroca Batida de Coco shines in place of RumChata when making Pina Coladas, coconut martinis, or other tropical cocktails. Feel free to use it in coconut cake recipes too.

Pineapple Perfection – Blue Chair Bay Pineapple Rum Cream

You can always count on Blue Chair Bay for quality flavored rums, including their Pineapple Rum Cream. This delightful liqueur combines juicy tropical pineapple with Jamaican rum and silky coconut cream.

It reminds me of sipping Pina Coladas on the beach. Thanks to its fruity profile, Blue Chair Bay Pineapple Rum Cream works nicely swapped into Piña Coladas, Chi-Chis, and other rum cocktails.

Whip Up Homemade RumChata

If you want to personalize your RumChata experience, try making it at home. This simple 4-ingredient recipe allows you to whip up homemade RumChata easily using ingredients you likely have on hand.

Here’s what you’ll need:

• 1 cup white sugar
• 1 cup water
• 1 cup spiced rum (like Bacardi)
• 2 cups heavy cream
• 1-2 tsp ground cinnamon
• 1 tsp vanilla extract
• Pinch of nutmeg (optional)

First, heat the sugar and water together, stirring until the sugar dissolves. Allow this simple syrup to cool slightly.

Next, use an electric mixer to beat the heavy cream on high speed until fluffy and almost whip cream-like. Gently fold in the spiced rum, cinnamon, vanilla and optional nutmeg by hand using a spatula.

Finally, slowly drizzle in the simple syrup while folding to evenly blend. Refrigerate for at least one hour before enjoying.

For a dairy-free version, swap out the heavy cream for 2 cups rice milk, soy milk, almond milk or canned coconut milk. Adjust sweetener to taste if needed.

Final Thought: RumChata Substitutes For Every Occasion

As you can see, RumChata has no shortage of tasty substitutes for mixing and sipping. The options above allow you to enjoy cream liqueurs with unique flavors ranging from rich chocolate to bright tropical fruit.

I like keeping a few liqueurs like these on hand to spice up evening cocktails or after-dinner drinks. And it doesn’t hurt to have a creamy cocktail ingredient ready for pouring over cakes and brownies too.

So next time your recipe calls for RumChata, consider one of these substitutes to change things up. Just be sure to drink responsibly and avoid overdoing it with these sweet temptations.