The 7 Best Restaurants in Churchville, NY (2024 Updated)

The small town of Churchville, NY has established itself as a hidden gem for incredible dining experiences. With a rich history and reputation for hospitality, Churchville offers a diverse range of cuisines to appeal to locals and visitors alike. From fine dining to casual eateries, here are 7 must-try restaurants that exemplify the best of Churchville’s food scene.

The Johnson House

Address: 19 S Main St, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

The Johnson House has been a staple of fine dining in Churchville since its doors first opened in 1885. Housed in a historic building from Churchville’s early days, this family-owned restaurant is known for its exceptional service, intimate ambiance, and exquisitely prepared meals. Reservations are highly recommended, as tables book up weeks in advance.

As soon as you step through the doors of The Johnson House, the warmth and charm envelop you. Live piano music fills the dining rooms, which offer a range of seating options – from cozy booths to private dining areas. Appetizers like Jumbo Shrimp and clams casino whet your appetite for the main courses to come. Signature dishes include the melt-in-your-mouth Filet Mignon with Lobster Tail, as well as classics like New England Clam Chowder. Save room for decadent desserts, with the New York Cheesecake and Chocolate Ganache Cake as standouts. A meal at The Johnson House is one to savor and remember.

Sunny Garden

Address: 12 S Main St, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

Beyond Churchville’s classic American fare, Sunny Garden adds diverse flavor with authentic Chinese cuisine. This unassuming restaurant surprises diners with efficient service and huge portions. The Liu family oversees day-to-day operations, with the kids pitching in after school. Their hard work has paid off with dishes that keep fans returning again and again.

General Tso’s Chicken, Sweet and Sour Chicken and House Special Lo Mein top the favorites’ list. Combination platters let diners sample an array of classics, with hot cups of Wonton soup starting off each meal. Sunny Garden’s outdoor seating offers a chance to enjoy the mild weather while taking in views of neighboring Churchville Park. This local spot adds welcome diversity to the town’s restaurant line-up.

Pontillo’s Pizzerias

Address: 32 S Main St, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

No list of treasured Churchville eateries would be complete without mentioning Pontillo’s Pizzerias. This Western New York chain has maintained a fiercely loyal following for almost 70 years, including here in Churchville. While each location is independently owned and operated, they share a passion for quality, authenticity and community.

The extensive menus have everything from oven-fresh pizzas and submarine sandwiches to wings, pasta and more. Pizza highlights include bubbling hot original and thin crust pies, with toppings like spicy buffalo chicken and classic pepperoni. Their famous chicken wings draw fans for signature sauces ranging from mild to the extra-spicy “Boss.”

With roots as a small mom-and-pop shop, Pontillo’s success stems from keeping community and customers at the forefront. As locals would say, their pizzas and wings simply “hit the spot!”

My Kinda Place

Address: 7100 W Buffalo Rd, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

Formerly known as the Churchville Family Restaurant and Bar, My Kinda Place has made its mark as a down-home eatery known for bountiful breakfasts. Locals flock here to fuel up on morning favorites like fluffy pancakes, hearty omelets, and all kinds of egg dishes. Lunchtime brings soups made from scratch, piled-high deli sandwiches, and juicy burgers.

As a nod to its Western New York locale, My Kinda Place serves Zweigle’s famous red and white hots – don’t leave without trying them! Friday nights feature an expanded menu with regional specialties like stuffed peppers and fried fish platters. And car enthusiasts won’t want to miss Monday Cruise Night in partnership with the nearby Barnard Chevrolet dealership.

Armstrong’s Main Street Deli

Address: 8 S Main St, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

Ask any Churchville local where to grab an authentic deli lunch, and they’ll surely point you to Armstrong’s Main Street Deli. This family-owned shop prides itself on home-style cooking, quality ingredients, and large portions for fair prices. Their case overflows with Boar’s Head meats and cheeses for filling sandwiches and subs on freshly baked breads.

Beyond the classics, Armstrong’s inventive specials showcase seasonal produce and regional flavors. The pizza oven churns out crispy thin crust pies, with the Margherita being a perennial favorite. Whether you dine in or take out, Armstrong’s warm, friendly service makes you feel like one of the regulars. It’s easy to see why they have been a community pillar for decades.

Churchville Grill

Address: 42 S Main St, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

Once a casual diner, Churchville Grill reopened after renovations as a lively sports bar serving elevated pub grub. While menus change seasonally, you can always count on a stellar lineup of appetizers, salads, burgers and more. Daily specials like the Iceberg Wedge Salad show off the kitchen’s creativity with fresh ingredients. More adventurous eaters will love menu surprises like Smoked Chicken Wings and zesty Fish Tacos.

Of course, the burgers deserve their own spotlight here. Locals rave about signatures like Bryan’s Smokehouse Burger, packed with bacon, cheddar, onion rings and smoky barbecue sauce. With plenty of local beers on tap and a full bar, Churchville Grill offers a fun, spirited mealtime option. Major kudos to owner Joe Bonafedo and his talented team of chefs!

Stone’s Countryside

Address: 6120 Buffalo Rd, Churchville, NY 14428, United States

For a quintessential family restaurant experience in Churchville, look no further than Stone’s Countryside. Three generations of the Stone family have maintained this cozy eatery’s reputation for hospitality, generosity, and scratch cooking. Their homemade soups are a trademark, with the cream of broccoli being a standout. Chicken and biscuits, meatloaf, pot roast and other comforting dishes keep regulars coming back.

While the menu honors tried-and-true favorites, Stone’s also impresses with seasonal specials. Think hand-breaded fish fries on Fridays, or the Golfer’s Special with a burger, chips and a beer. Though a tragic fire in 2020 closed their doors for a time, Stone’s has proudly reopened with a fresh retro look. Their spirit of community endures, drawing loyal customers – some who first dined there as children themselves.

This sampling of Churchville’s top restaurants reveals the breadth of options for unforgettable dining experiences here. From the elegance of The Johnson House to the small town charm of Stone’s Countryside, local eateries exemplify quality, hospitality and connection.

Food lovers are encouraged to explore these seven highlights and discover their own Churchville favorites. Experience the charm of a family-owned deli like Armstrong’s, or expand your culinary horizons at Sunny Garden. We invite you to join the conversation and share your own can’t-miss dining spots. With such an array of restaurants to choose from, the only challenge is deciding where to eat next!